Powered by JoomlaGadgets


Login





Lost Password?
No account yet? Register
Phone contact
0845 223 3079
polls
Poll of the day
Home arrow Blog arrow Should obese people be paid to lose weight?
Should obese people be paid to lose weight?
So a health think tank is making this suggestion, claiming that in a couple of areas of the country where this has been trialled it has been successful.

Part of the rationale behind this is that in the long term, if people do indeed lose weight because they are paid to do it, it will be less of a drain on the public purse because, having lost weight, they are less likely to need expensive medication and/or surgical intervention for obesity related illnesses.

But is it ethical? And does it really work? What about if the weight is regained - should the money be returned?

On a personal level, have you ever gone on a sponsored slim to raise money for some good cause?  How effective was that - both in the short and long term?

What do you think about this?  Share your thoughts on this page

 

Comments  

 
-1 #1 Chris Vickery 2010-09-09 07:34
I do occasionally have diet fizzy drinks, they help to make me feel full!
I don't understand how diet drinks can promote obesity?
Quote
 
 
0 #2 Mrs Julie Wheeler 2011-08-27 10:15
Interesting! I am thinking about initiating a sponsored slim! I came to this website to see if I might find some further info. What do people think?

I would find the incentive of raising money for a charity helpful on various levels. Most significantly it would provide an indirect way of raising the profile of one important issue. Whether or not we have disordered eating habits, collectively in the west we overeat. Alongside that, there are those across our world who are literally starving. That point seems to be very hard for us to face, especially if we ourselves have issues regarding eating. We can feel powerless to do anything about it. Raising money for the poor and hungry would be a small way of redressing the balance, wouldn?t it?

I have wrestled with God regarding my own eating habits for three years. This year I've been able to start putting some of the F4LF principles into practice ; with varying levels of success :sigh:!
Quote
 
 
0 #3 Mrs Julie Wheeler 2011-08-27 10:18
ran out of symbols one previous comment... just wanted to add.. I've been very grateful for the work of F4LF. It's teaching and outworking of Christian principles...Thank you.
Quote
 
 
0 #4 lianne 2011-11-07 18:48
i don't personally find sponsored slimming works because the pressure increases my stress which increases my eating. that has been with previous diets tho. am waiting to receive the book for this plan so you never know i might be able to do a sponsored slim yet!
can't wait to start this programme esp as i KNOW it won't compromise my Christian beliefs!
Quote
 

Add comment


Security code
Refresh